Forks Up, Indy! Why The Old Spaghetti Factory is the Pasta Palace You’ve Been Craving

🍝Forks Up, Indy! Why The Old Spaghetti Factory is the Pasta Palace You’ve Been Craving

July 17, 2025•2 min read

Listen up, pasta people—if you haven’t been to The Old Spaghetti Factory in downtown Indianapolis, you are seriously missing out on some next-level noodle nirvana. We’re talkin’ vintage vibes, insanely good Italian food, and a whole dining experience that’ll make you feel like you stepped into a cozy, candlelit time machine—but with garlic bread. This isn’t just a dinner stop; it’s a full-blown culinary event that’s been winning over hearts (and stomachs) since the ‘60s. Oh, and let’s not forget it’s just a hop and a skip from all kinds of cool downtown hotspots—double win.

🎯What Makes This Place So Dang Special?

  • 🍝 Hearty Classics — Think rich lasagna, creamy fettuccine alfredo, chicken parm, and their signature Mizithra Cheese & Browned Butter Pasta that people literally write love letters about

  • 🥖 All-In-One Meals — Every entrĂŠe comes with hot sourdough bread, soup or salad, and a scoop of spumoni ice cream—like, who does that anymore?!

  • 🚂 Dining in a Trolley Car — Yep, there’s a vintage streetcar INSIDE the restaurant that you can dine in. It’s quirky, fun, and absolutely Instagram-worthy

  • 👪 Perfect for Families — Big portions, fun decor, and a kids’ menu that doesn’t feel like an afterthought

  • 🍷 Affordable Date Night Vibes — The dim lighting and antique chandeliers turn any regular dinner into chef’s kiss date material without draining your wallet

💡Bonus Bites: The Old Spaghetti Factory Fun Facts

  • Started in Portland in 1969 and still keeps that old-school charm alive

  • Every location is decked out with antique furniture, stained glass windows, and a trolley car because ✨aesthetic✨

  • The Indianapolis spot is housed in a historic building that just oozes charm and character

🗺️What’s Around the Corner? (AKA Pre- or Post-Pasta Adventures)

  • 🎭 Old National Centre for a show or concert—just minutes away

  • 🏀 Gainbridge Fieldhouse if you’re catching a Pacers game or big event

  • 🍺 Sun King Brewery for a craft beer and chill vibe nearby

  • 🎨 The Eiteljorg Museum for a little culture before carbs

  • 🛍️ Circle Centre Mall if you wanna walk off that pasta coma with some retail therapy

📸Pro Tip
Bring your phone fully charged. Between the moody lighting, cozy corners, and that epic trolley car, you’re gonna want pics for the ‘Gram. Tag your post-dinner glow-up with #PastaGoals and watch the likes roll in.

🕰️When to Go

  • Open daily for lunch and dinner with solid weekend hours—pro tip: weekdays are less crowded, so you’ll likely snag a trolley seat

  • Wanna avoid the rush? Go between 2-5PM for a quiet, mid-afternoon feast

🚗✨If you're already planning your Italian night out in downtown Indy, why not cruise there in style? Prime Edge Car Rentals has your perfect ride waiting. Whether you’re heading out for pasta with friends or turning dinner into a romantic evening, we’ve got wheels to match your mood. Book now at Prime Edge Car Rentals or give us a ring at +1 463-348-2212—let’s get you on the road to ravioli, baby!







One-Way Airport Car Rental Indianapolis INAirport Pickup Car Rentals IndianapolisCar Rentals Near IND AirportIndianapolis Airport Car RentalsCorporate Car Rentals IndianapolisIndianapolis Car Rental PromotionsDiscount Car Rentals Indianapolis INIndianapolis Car Rental SpecialsIndianapolis IN Rental Car SpecialsShort-Term Car Rentals IndianapolisHybrid Car Rentals Indianapolis INFamily Car Rentals IndianapolisIndianapolis Chauffeur ServicesPremium Car Rentals IndianapolisExotic Car Rentals Indianapolis INDiscount Car Rentals IndianapolisBest Car Rental Deals IndianapolisAirport Car Rentals Indianapolis INOne-Way Car Rentals IndianapolisLong-Term Car Rentals Indianapolis INWeekly Car Rentals IndianapolisConvenient Car Rentals Indianapolis INCar Rentals IndianapolisLuxury Car Rentals Indianapolis IN
Back to Blog

Have a question for us?

Contact Us

Why Choose Us!

Avoid the lengthy queues and hassle of conventional car rentals. Choose our service, and your luxury vehicle will be delivered directly to your chosen location, precisely when it's most convenient for you.

In a special show of gratitude, we provide an exclusive white-glove concierge service that includes a personalized check-in at your hotel or residence, ensuring a smooth and effortless experience.

About Us

As a proud Veteran-owned and operated business, we bring the same level of dedication and attention to detail that we’ve applied throughout our service. Whether it’s the flawless condition of the vehicle or the personalized care, you can trust that every experience is handled with the utmost integrity and commitment.

Contact us!

Telephone:

+1 463-348-2212

Location:

Indianapolis. IN

Our business hours

24/7

Prime Edge Car Rentals, All Rights Reserved, 2024